Ξ 3 comments

Thoughts on the BBC TV series “I’m in a Rock ‘n’ Roll Band!”

posted by
Thoughts on the BBC TV series “I’m in a Rock ‘n’ Roll Band!”

I’m absolutely sold by most “rockumentary” programmes, whether it’s talking about the hippies living in Laurel Canyon or Metallica recording the “Black Album”, I’m not too fussed. I just love discovering all the fine details about how musicians, especially guitarists, develop their art and creativity.

If you didn’t see any of the BBC “I’m in a Rock ‘n’ Roll Band!” TV programme, the concept is fairly simple. It was a six-part series investigating what constructs the perfect rock ‘n’ roll band where the BBC and influential rock musicians described the important role each band member has, detailed various characteristics (typically stereotypical) of each member and gave the general public the opportunity to vote for who they consider to be the best Rock n Roll band member of all time.

I’d better get my rants out of the way early on. Firstly I was miffed to see that the bass player only had 30 minutes exposure on the programme that was harshly entitled “The other one”, where the BBC mixed a single episode with bassists, keyboard players, dancers and anyone else who helped to form a rock band. I was disappointed as I personally thought a whole hour should’ve been devoted entirely to the bassist. You could also argue that although the programme was focussed on being in a Rock n Roll band, the BBC left out a variety of musicians who could have easily been included in the voting selection list.

The series culminated on Saturday evening in a live TV broadcast where we were notified of the top three musicians who had successfully been voted into each respective category. This was followed by numerous “celebrities” debating why each of these musicians deserved the mantle of being the greatest of all time.

The final three guitarists were presented to us and to be honest I wasn’t too surprised at the list. Jimi Hendrix, Jimmy Page and Slash made it through which was fairly predictable, although I did raise an eyebrow at Slash being included. If I was really honest, I was shouting “Where the hell is Jeff Beck!” at my TV screen.

After a couple of hours of listening to the “celebrities” argue their case for who they think should win the various awards we were finally informed that Hendrix picked up the accolade for being voted the greatest Rock n Roll guitarist of all time. I was personally torn between Hendrix and Page, mainly due to the huge array of fantastic riffs Page has created over the years – but the live DVDs I have of Hendrix really display a creative genius full of energy, rhythm and charisma that must have blown away both fellow musicians and numerous audiences throughout the late 1960s. His “Band of Gypsies” album is still one of my favourite live recordings.

Overall, I was a little disappointed with the final TV programme but I was happy with the voting result. Just think, to actually have the opportunity to see the winning musicians on stage at the same time in a “super group” would really be something!

BBC Results:

  • Singer: Freddie Mercury
  • Guitar: Jimi Hendrix
  • Bass: Flea
  • Drums: John Bonham

So I guess this leaves me to ask a final question: Who would you have in your Rock n Roll super group? If I choose to ignore the actual selection the BBC offered I’d probably go with the following:

  • Singer: Freddie Mercury
  • Guitar: Jimi Hendrix
  • Bass: John Entwistle
  • Drums: Nicko McBrain

Share This Article

You may also like...

Submit your equipment reviews

Do you own a guitar, amp, effects pedal or guitar accessory that you love (or hate!). If so, become a Guitar Jar Magazine Contributor and submit your reviews for other guitarists to read.

About the author:

Sam is passionate about talking all things guitar related and started GuitarJar.co.uk to help encourage all guitarists in their guitar playing journey.

3 Comments

  • I would go for either..

    Singer/Keys: Stevie Wonder
    Guitar: (Me) Derek Trucks
    Bass: James Jamerson
    Drums: Steve Jordan

    or

    Singer/Guitar: Ray Lamontagne
    Singer/Guitar: Bon Iver
    Guitar/Singer: Doyle Bramhall II
    Guitar: Jeff Beck
    Bass: James Jamerson
    Drums: JJ Johnson
    Songwriter/Singer: Bob Dylan

  • +1 on James Jamerson. Awesome bass player.

  • I’ve been watching this series again on BBC3 and just wanted to share this clip of Johnny Marr. Loved it when he demos This Charming Man. Great guitarist, I really love his style of playing… shame about Morrisey’s vocals!!!

    Johnny Marr – ‘This Charming Man’ – I’m In A Rock ‘n’ Roll Band on YouTube

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Search Guitar Jar Magazine

Hang out with us

Magazine Spotlights

Sign up to our Mailing List

* indicates required

I'm interested in: